Farm Family Recipes
Find Family Recipes
Recipe Details:
Back
Grandma Gertie’s Pumpkin Pie
Provided by:
Brett Hickman, Hickman's Family Farms
Ingredients:
- 1 9-inch Pie Crust
- 1/3 large can of Pumpkin
- 5 Hickman large egg yolks
- 1 cup sugar
- 1 tsp pumpkin pie spice
- 1 tblsp vanilla
- 1 1/2 cans evaporated milk
Directions:
In large mixing bowl, mix sugar and spice together, set aside. In mixer bowl, blend egg yolks one at a time into pumpkin, then add milk, sugar/spice, and vanilla on low. Pour mixture into 9-inch pie shell and bake at 350 degrees until filling sets, 35-40+ minutes depending on oven. Brett Hickman suggests topping it with a mountain of whip cream!!!
Source: Hickman Family Farms â¦
Where You Can Buy Ingredients:
| Farm Name | Owner Name | Address | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| A Bar H Farm | Anya Owens and Josh Koehn | PO Box 66, San Simon, AZ, 85632 | View |
| Abraham’s Faith Garden | - | HC 65 Box 33416, Concho, Arizona, 85924 | View |
| Adams Family Farms | Wayne Adams | 17455 South Round Mountain Road, Dewey, AZ, 86327 | View |
| Agua Linda Farm | Laurel Loew | 2643 E. Frontage Rd., Amado, AZ, 85645 | View |
| Apple Annies | Annie Holcomb | 2081 W. Hardy Rd., Willcox, AZ, 85643 | View |
| Bathtub Spring Farm | Gary & Marilyn Hart | 40 CR 2130 PO Box 224, Nutrioso, AZ, 85932 | View |
| Buckelew Farm Pumpkin Festival & Corn Maze | Clint Buckelew | 17000 W. Ajo Way, Tucson, AZ, 85735 | View |
| Chile Acres | Jimmie & Celia Peterson | 3247 S. 343rd Avenue, Tonopah, Arizona, 85354 | View |
| Collier Farm | Rhonda Collier | 690 W. Rd 5 North, Chino Valley, AZ, 86323 | View |
| Crow’s Dairy, Inc | Wendell & Rhonda Crow - Mary Lou & Erik Hernandez | 11300 S. Dean Road, Buckeye, Arizona, 85326 | View |
| Double Blessings | Kathryn Marshall | 4062 N Colt Rd, Apache Junction, AZ, 85119 | View |
| Hickman’s Family Farms | Sharman Hickman | 6515 S. Jackrabbit Trail, Buckeye, Arizona, 85326 | View |
| Hopkins Hog Farm | Elija Hopkins | PO Box 398, Aguila, AZ, 85320 | View |
| JH Grass Fed | - | PO Box 63, Cave Creek, Arizona, 85327 | View |
| La Buena Vida Farm | Jerry Racicot | 8883 E. Turquoise Road, Portal, Arizona, 85632 | View |
| Lewis’ Hen House & Veggie Farm | Doug Henderson | , , , | View |
| Lunt Bunch Pumpkins | Terrol & Kimberly Lunt | 205 Lovers Lane, Duncan, AZ, 85534 | View |
| M Triangle Ranch | Mark & Shelley Michaels | 19099 S. Wells Road, Bonita, Arizona, 85643 | View |
| Moonrise Farms | Jimmy Videle & Lorraine Wiesen | HC 65 Box 527026, Concho, AZ, 85294 | View |
| Mother Nature’s Farm | Wade Kelsall | 1663 E. Baseline Rd., Gilbert, AZ, 85233-1542 | View |
| Patriot’s Dream Farm | - | 11800 West Sandario Place, Tucson, Arizona, 85735 | View |
| San Ysidro Farm | Nathan and Jackie Watkins | 9225 N Frontier Rd., McNeal, AZ, 85617 | View |
| Schnepf Farms | Carrie Schnepf | 24810 S. Rittenhouse Rd, Queen Creek, AZ, 85242 | View |
| Superstition Farm | Casey Stechnij, Jason and Alison Crittenden | 3440 S Hawes Rd, Mesa, AZ, 85212 | View |
| The Cotton Shedd, LLC | Rodney & Tiffany Shedd | 12122 S. Toltec Buttes Road, Eloy, Arizona, 85131 | View |
| The Simple Farm | Michael and Lylah Ledner | 9080 East Cactus Road, Scottsdale, AZ, 85260 | View |
| Tolmachoff Farms | Bill & Grace Tolmachoff | 5726 N. 75th Ave, Glendale, AZ, 85303 | View |
| Vertuccio Farms | - | - | View |
Popular Ingredients:
Our Latest Posts
The “Food as Medicine” Trend in 2025: Promise and Pitfalls
By Julie Murphree, Arizona Farm Bureau Director of Strategic Communications As we move into 2025, the “food as medicine” movement is poised to take center…
Pork and Nutrition: Taste What Pork Can Do!
By Joel Carr, Arizona Farm Bureau Strategic Communications Manager, and Julie Murphree, Strategic Communications Director When building a healthy, nutrient-rich plate, pork delivers in…
